sound_matter
Member
- Joined
- Mar 1, 2020
- Messages
- 5
- Likes
- 3
Interesting discussion. I do agree that having a voting system in the review is odd. The method is not scientific, but public critique which can be a subjective view. At the same time, I can see that votes from ASR audience can be a valuable criticism to a manufacturer.
If a manufacturer disagree with the criticism in this forum, that should be fine. Because FR response is not the only factor to measuring HPs. For me, data in ASR reviews are good reference to understand characteristics of gears and compare with others. But they are not a final closer for my decision making since there are other aspects that cannot be measured scientifically yet.
If a manufacturer disagree with the criticism in this forum, that should be fine. Because FR response is not the only factor to measuring HPs. For me, data in ASR reviews are good reference to understand characteristics of gears and compare with others. But they are not a final closer for my decision making since there are other aspects that cannot be measured scientifically yet.