Ok, I see your argument. Not buying it, though. I believe the smidgen stronger motor will make that a non-factor (keeping all things equal) compared to the inherent advantages I've listed.
If you want to make me believe you, you will have to impress me in a dedicated thread!
Ok, let me give one more attempt: as frequency raises drivers get's smaller, so obviously larger is not always better. Once you introduce a sub in your speaker and task it with low bass it may be that smaller woofer would better do the job in higher bass than larger woofer who's strength is only low bass which sub anyhow does better.
I would glady try to impress you but you should first demonstrate you're cute enough to deserve it.